The Long Island Wedding Venues We Love Most
An editorial guide and a data tool from the team that has worked weddings across the Gold Coast, the North Fork, the South Shore, and everywhere between. The venues we love, the couples they serve best, and everything we have learned along the way.
There are hundreds of wedding venues across Long Island and the New York metro. These are some of our favorites.
This is an editorial guide and a data tool, built together. Every venue is here because we have actually worked there or know it well enough to recommend it confidently. The notes are honest. The pricing guidance is what we have seen firsthand. The "best for" calls are based on the couples we have watched have the best day at each place. And when you want to compare them side by side, the table further down lets you sort by location, style, price tier, or whatever matters most to you.
The venues below are organized by the kind of wedding they serve best, not ranked. A Gold Coast estate in Old Westbury is not better or worse than a North Fork winery or an oceanfront hotel in Long Beach. They are different. The question is which one is right for you.
Beyond these favorites, we are building out the full Long Island directory venue by venue. New spoke pages publish weekly. If you do not see one you are considering, our Long Island team can research it for you.
Signed, Kristine and the Toast Long Island Team
Where Kristine Works Most
The six Long Island venues our team works at most often. She knows the staff, the load-in, the timeline, and the parts of the day that need a steady hand.
True oceanfront in Long Beach, with the ceremony on the sand, the reception in a polished indoor or rooftop space, and hotel rooms upstairs for out-of-town family.
Part of the Long Island Aquarium on the Peconic River, with the 5,300-square-foot Sea Star Ballroom, a Coliseum Room lined with tropical tanks, and a riverside pavilion for outdoor ceremonies, up to 650 guests.
A restored 1860s mansion on 22 acres of gardens and farmland, paired with a rustic barn and an on-site speakeasy, with overnight stays built in. Kristine has coordinated weddings here and calls it the North Fork's best fit for smaller, story-driven celebrations.
Fourteen riverfront acres of gardens and greenhouses in Calverton, rented as a blank canvas for tented weddings of 50 to 150 guests from June through October.
A Lessing's estate on the North Fork with garden ceremonies, a vine-draped patio for cocktails, and a renovated Grand Ballroom for up to 250 seated, one wedding at a time and no site fee. Kristine has coordinated weddings here and knows the flow from the garden to the ballroom by heart.
More Long Island Favorites
Four more properties across the North Fork, the North Shore, the Gold Coast, and the South Shore that we recommend without hesitation.
A multi-acre property in St. James with gardens, orchards, vineyards, an indoor atrium, and an island gazebo, so every part of the grounds delivers a different backdrop. The North Shore answer for couples who want landscape-driven photos with the structure of a full-service catering venue.
Tudor-style estate on the NYIT campus in Old Westbury, with a marble foyer, sweeping staircase, formal interiors, and landscaped ceremony grounds. Classic Long Island estate energy without the rate cards some Gold Coast peers carry.
A clean, modern estate winery in Riverhead surrounded by vineyards and farmland, with wide views that need little added to make an impact. Resort-style on the North Fork, with the option to build the wedding around a full destination weekend.
Overlooks the Bay Shore Marina with boats, sunsets, and open water as the room's whole personality, from the relaxed Harborview Room with deck access to the ballroom-style Bayview House. Food-forward, marina-side, easy energy.
Side-by-side, no scrolling required
Sort the table by any column to compare venue locations, styles, and best-fit scenarios.
Price tiers reflect typical venue-rental spend on a peak Saturday, before catering, bar, or vendors. Off-peak dates and Friday or Sunday weddings run noticeably lower. Our Long Island team can pull current pricing for any venue on this list.
| Venue | Neighborhood | Style | Price Tier | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Allegria Hotel | Long Beach | Oceanfront Hotel | $$$ | Beach ceremony + indoor reception |
| Atlantis Banquets & Events | Riverhead | Riverfront Aquarium Venue | $$$ | Big guest lists with a wow factor |
| Jedediah Hawkins Inn | Jamesport | North Fork Historic Inn | $$$ | Intimate weekend stays |
| Peconic River Herb Farm | Calverton | Riverfront Farm | $$ | Tented outdoor weddings |
| The Vineyards at Aquebogue | Aquebogue | North Fork Vineyard Estate | $$$ | Garden ceremony + ballroom reception |
| Flowerfield Celebrations | St. James | North Shore Estate | $$$ | Garden-driven photos |
| NYIT de Seversky Mansion | Old Westbury | Gold Coast Mansion | $$$$ | Formal estate weddings |
| RGNY | Riverhead | North Fork Vineyard | $$$ | Destination-style weddings |
| Captain Bill's | Bay Shore | South Shore Marina | $$ | Food-forward waterfront |
A local owner, a real team, same-day help.
Planning a Long Island wedding is a lot. Our team exists to take some of that off your plate. Led by Kristine, our Long Island Franchise Owner, we know the rooms, the staff, the seasonal quirks, and the day-to-day rhythms of every venue on this page. Pricing, availability, comparing options, figuring out which property actually fits what you are looking for.
You can call, text, or email. A real person on the Long Island team answers. There is no sales pitch and no obligation to book Toast for anything.
- Build a custom shortlist of Long Island venues based on your guest count, style, and budget.
- Reach out to the venues you are considering to check live availability for your date.
- Help you understand what each venue actually charges, including the costs that are not always listed publicly.
- Recommend vendors for the services Toast does not provide, from caterers to florists to officiants.
- Answer the questions you were not sure who to ask. No sales pressure, no obligation, no script.
Let our team make this easier
Tell us what you are imagining. Our Long Island team will put together a custom shortlist of venues for you, with honest notes on what each one is actually like.
Your Long Island shortlist
Two minutes. We get back to you the same day.
Honest answers to the real questions
Every Long Island wedding venue we know
A growing library beyond our favorites. New venues added every week. If you do not see one, the Long Island team can research it for you.
Twenty-eight Long Island and metro NY venues, growing every week. Goal: every venue in the market.
